o　—　but　SHE！”

Well；　“She”　came　out　and　was　a　great　success。　On　March　15th　Charles　Longman　wrote　to　me　in　Egypt：

I　am　glad　to　tell　you　that　“She”　keeps　on　selling　capitally。　We　have　printed　25；000　already；　and　have　ordered　another　5000；　and　I　do　not　think　we　shall　have　many　left　when　the　printers　deliver　them。　。　。　。　Last　week　we　sold　over　1000　copies！

This　was　a　large　number　as　books　sold　in　those　days；　when　people　were　not　accustomed　to　buying　novels　in　one　volume；　having　been　in　the　habit　of　borrowing　them　from　the　library　in　three。　Moreover；　from　that　day　to　this　the　sale　of　“She”　has　never　ceased；　whilst　in　America　it　was　pirated　by　the　hundred　thousand。

All　the　reviews　of　it　were　not　good；　indeed　some　of　them　attacked　it　strongly。　Others；　were　enthusiastic。　The　Times　（a　review　in　The　Times　then；　before　the　days　of　Literary　Supplements；　if　good；　was　very　valuable）　spoke　extremely　well　of　it。　The　Times　reviewer；　however；　criticises　the　Greek　upon　the　sherd。　Had　he　known　that　it　was　the　work　of　Dr。　Holden；　one　of　the　best　Greek　scholars　of　the　day；　he　might　have　preferred　to　leave　it　unquestioned。　Here　is　the　doctor’s　letter　on　the　subject；　written　from　the　Athenaeum　in　March　1886。

Dear　Haggard；　—　Your　task　is　not　quite　so　big　as　one　of　the　labours　of　Hercules；　but　by　no　means　easy　without　further　data。　Do　you　want　the　Greek　to　be　such　as　to　deceive　the　learned　world　into　thinking　that　it　is　no　forgery；　but　a　genuine　bit　of　antiquity？　If　so